Are we worrying about the right things?
Let's have a look at what I think are the actual causes for our malaise in the world.
This sounds slightly snarky, but it is something that keeps bothering me in media and online discourse. What I see is people seizing on a current hype topic and demonising that. What I wish they'd do instead: Look at the actual causes for our malaise.
The following things are those that I think we should be very worried and angry about. These things are what I think need urgent fixing. Everything else is just a symptom of these being unfixed.
Double standards that favour the rich and powerful
We see this in many ways: How the very rich can evade taxes, how things that will land poor people in jail are at most an annoying fine for others, or how the same thing that made the US state mercilessly persecute Aaron Schwartz to the point where died by suicide is now viewed as "proper business" by big AI companies, even though the standing legal discourse seems pretty clear.
Those double standards undermine our trust and confidence in governments, courts, and law enforcement. They erode society, and they allow the the-less-than-powerful to be exploited.
That brings me to the next issue:
Exploitation as basic economic principle
This started when private persons and companies were able to buy or license things, and people, for exploitation. Meaning they were legally allowed, and often actually encouraged to use up resources and people. Until then, people mostly relied on farming land so that the land keept being arable and yielding crops for centuries. (Of course, this is oversimplified, but I hope you get my idea here.)
But you can extract minerals or other things from the land only once. If you take all the metal out of a parcel of land, that metal is gone. And depending on how you do it, it's pretty likely that the land is also unusable for a lot of other things afterwards.
Similarily, you can dump only so much CO2 in the atmosphere, only so much trash into the oceans, before we see horrendous long term negative effects for everyone else. So yes, pollution and the climate change crisis are a form of exploitation: People exploit the environment for their gain, because not polluting is more costly or prevents them from making a profit.
If you hire someone for a fair wage, they will enrich the broader economy. If you enslave them, or just pay them a pittance, you exploit them, use them up for your own profits.
Allowing private entities to exploit anything is a fundamental problem in our society. It allows the few to profit to the detriment of the many, and to the detriment of later generations. (This is by the way also the reason why the "Tragedy of the Commons" is a fallacy. The "Tragedy" only occurs when someone is able to exploit the commons because they know they can move on to a different commons once they've used the first one up. People who stay around are a lot less likely to do that.)
We see this issue in the rise of the Rentier class, and in Venture Capitalism. It is the underlying driver for Enshittification, the gig economy and people not making a living wage on a single job. And usually, they are then misled about the reasons why this is so. How?
Racism and similar hate that is othering people.
This is a terrible tool wielded by those who want to keep themselves in power, real or perceived. They convince those that are not in power that it is actually "the other" that is to blame for their problems.[1] The insidious part is that it self-propagates and then permeates all the other parts of society and how we live together. There is the (in my eyes eminently credible) claim that nearly all of the USAs societal and political problems can be traced to racism.
We see the same thing applied to nearly every minority now and then, and it is not only shameful, it hurts everyone else too. It hurts us all because aside from the moral compromises it gets us in, it usually adds otherwise wholly unnecessary barriers to access things we all need.
So we end up with...
The dismantling of public infrastructure.
To be really precise, this is not a root cause in itself, but the consequence of the above problems. But it is a consequence that is in itself creating a massive problem for everyone that has to rely on public infrastructure instead of just building or buying something for themselves.
That way, it makes the ability to function easily and comfortably in our society utterly dependent on being wealthy enough to do so. And the more infrastructure is dismantled or paywalled, the fewer people can participate, the more get disenfranchised. And that in turn funnels wealth and power upwards, to even higher concentrations.
Concentration of power and wealth.
The less equal we are as a society, the more those with power and wealth can use that to deepen the inequality, to make use of issues outlined above to entrench themselves at the cost of everyone else.
This concentration then speed-runs all the above problems. It is a vicious cycle, and to break it, we need to redistribute that wealth and power. And the longer we wait, the more radical, drastic, and maybe even violent that redistribution will have to be.
Conclusion
I honestly think that when we tackle the above things, we can start to evaluate other problems a lot more honestly and on their own merits, instead of putting blame on placeholder issues.
Everything else we see as problems is probably just a symptom of the above issues and bemoaning them are distractions.
The question that I pose to myself then is: Why do we look at the placeholder issues and distractions instead at the root causes?
Is it ideology ("I want to believe in the American Dream"), is it the fear of ostracisation ("if I process to 'commie' ideas, people won't like me anymore"), or is it, as I sometimes fear, the lack of deeper thinking, insight, or the willingness to look past the cause du jour and concentrate on finding root causes?
This may be a post about the state of AI discourse.
I am also perfectly aware of the irony that I use the "othering" shorthand of the "Rich and Powerful" a lot here. ↩︎
Weiterlesen
Rhon - eine Rollenspiel-Rezension
Vor knapp zwei Wochen bekam ich überraschend eine Email, die mich einlud, doch einmal das Folkhorror Rollenspiel Rhon zu rezensieren. Da es ebenso wie mein Mail Order Apocalypse auf Into the Odd aufsetzt, fühlte ich mich ungemein geeignet, und wir einigten uns auf einen Review-Tausch. Ich bekam von Philipp
Ork'sche Technologieeinschätzungen
Jede Technologie, die menschliche Arbeit wegautomatisiert, finde ich grundsätzlich erst einmal gut!
Developing with LLMs, coda
Yes, I do want my cake (developing with LLMs) and eat it too (have an equitable, green, and fair society where everyone flourishes).
a critical look at LLMs and myself
I work at a medical research institute that has worked on "artificial intelligence" long before the rise of LLMs. That's not what I work on here, but I get exposed to their work and have conversations. I also have friends (because I'm a nerd)